Appeals 101: What is an Appeal?

What exactly is an appeal, and how is it different from a trial court action? The most important answer I can give you is what an appeal is not: it is not simply a “do over” where the appellate court gets to re-weigh the evidence and substitute its judgment for that of the trial judge.

Instead, an appeals court is a reviewing court, and it can only review for “preserved error.” There are two components to “preserved error.”

What is Preserved Error?

First, there has to be error of some kind. This is generally either a misinterpretation of the law, or a misapplication of the law to the facts, or rarely an “abuse of discretion” in interpreting the facts (like finding the facts sufficient when they clearly are not, and no reasonable judge should have found them to be sufficient). In addition, some “calls” that a trial court makes, even if we think it was the wrong call, are reviewed for discretion, and the appellate court can’t overturn it even if the appellate judges think “I would have done it differently if I were the trial judge.”

Second, it needs to be preserved. That is, there needs to be a proper objection made and ruled on, or the argument that you want to make on appeal has to have been made to the trial court, and that has to be reflected on the docket so that the appeals court can see exactly what was put in front of the trial court. In civil cases in Florida state courts, the parties need to hire a court reporter for hearings themselves and then pay for a transcript of the hearing in order to show the appellate court what happened at a hearing. Without a transcript, it is often impossible to make the required showings to win on appeal because you can’t show that your arguments and objections were preserved. (In Federal Court and in Florida criminal cases, proceedings are recorded and transcripts can be ordered at a later date without the parties’ needing to order a reporter).

Why you need a court reporter

Because of this preservation requirement, it often impossible to appeal if you have not taken all of the steps necessary to ensure that there is a complete record for the appellate court. It breaks my heart when I see cases that have real issues that simply were not preserved, and therefore make an appeal impossible to win. The most important thing you can do is make sure there is a court reporter at any hearing where important issues will come up — especially for summary judgment or for trial, but also for any other issue you think can affect the outcome of the case. Yes, there is a cost to this: Most court reporters charge an “appearance fee” for attending a hearing or trial. You do not need to order the actual transcript unless you need it for an appeal to assist with an argument before the trial court, but there is no transcript to be ordered if there is not a court reporter there. Zoom hearings are generally not recorded and you cannot assume there will be court reporter or recording just because the hearing was conducted by Zoom. This is why one of the first questions we ask when we assess an appeal is “was there a court reporter at the hearing”?

Standards of Review Matter

When we assess a case for possible appeal, we always start with very important question: What is the standard of review? I already talked about them above, though not in these terms. A standard of review is the lens through which the appellate court will review the trial court’s work. There are three main standards of review: Abuse of Discretion, De Novo, and sufficiency of the evidence.

Abuse of Discretion. If the trial court made what the law considers a discretionary call, then the appellate court will apply the “abuse of discretion” standard. And this means that the appeals court is looking for big problems, not just areas where the appellate judges might have made a different judgment call. This standard of review applies to most factual issues, as well as many rulings where the rules of procedure give the trial judge discretion to manage its docket. The abuse of discretion standard means that the trial court’s ruling has to be so wrong that no reasonable person would have come to the conclusion that the trial judge did. Appeals courts are very clear that it is not their job to second guess the trial court’s judgment calls, and that the trial court judge is the one who is “in it,” viewing live testimony and making split second judgment calls. Those judgments will not be disturbed on appeal unless they rise to the level of error, even if the appeals judges might have done things differently. If reasonable minds can differ, then the appellate court will defer to the trial court’s judgment.

De Novo. “De novo” is Latin for over again, or anew. As a standard of review, it means that the appeals court will look at the issue anew, and not give any deference to the trial court. This kind of review applies mostly to interpretation of statutes or contracts or the meaning of the law.

Sufficiency of the Evidence. When an appellate court is reviewing how the trial court applied the facts, is sometimes looking just to see if there is sufficient evidence in the record to support the trial court’s application of the law to the facts. The appellate court may be looking to see, for example, whether there is evidence to support every prong of a legal test.

Sometimes, more than one standard of review can apply in the same case — there may be several issues, with different standards of review, in the same case.

Assessing Your Appeal

We hope this article has been helpful to you as part of our continuing Appeals 101 series [link]. But remember, this article is for information only, and cannot really replace legal advice specific to your situation.
If you plan to handle your appeal by yourself, we recommend you consult the Florida Bar Appellate Practice Section’s Pro Se Handbook [link] for additional information. If you would like our professional analysis of your possible appeal, please contact us quickly, as there are significant deadlines in appeals that must be met or your appeal may be waived. You can request a review of your appeal by filling out our intake form here [link]. Based on the intake form, we will be able to quote you a fee for conducting an appeal assessment. Our appeal assessments look at these preservation issues as well as the underlying legal and factual issues to determine whether we believe we can make a winnable argument on appeal.

What Do I Do if the Other Side Files a Writ of Certiorari, Prohibition, or Mandamus in Florida Cases?

Writs of Certiorari, Writs of Mandamus, and Writs of Prohibition are three different ways a party in Florida state court litigation can seek appellate court intervention even though the judge has not made a final decision. If the other side seeks one of these writs from the appellate court, what do you need to do to protect yourself?

No Response Required — at First

The party who files a petition for a writ is referred to in the appellate court as the Petitioner, and the party who won the trial court victory is referred to in the appellate court is called the Respondent. But in most cases, a Respondent is neither required nor allowed to respond to the Petition. A response is only allowed if ordered by the appellate court. The appellate court will first review the petition and decide whether it needs or wants a response. Florida Rule of Appellate Procedure Rule 9.100(h) states that if the Court believes the petition “demonstrates a preliminary basis for relief,” the Court will issue an “order to show cause” asking the Respondent to explain why relief should not be granted. The Court could also instead direct the Respondent to file a response. Either order will state a deadline for the Respondent to respond.

Do I Need Appellate Counsel?

It is a good idea to consult with appellate counsel if the other side files a writ. Appellate counsel can help in several ways. First, appellate counsel can provide an initial assessment of how likely the appellate court is to request a response. Second, appellate counsel can be at the ready in case the appellate court does order a response. The Court will set a deadline, and depending on how urgent the issues in the petition are, the deadline might be quite fast. Bringing appellate counsel on board as soon as the writ is filed can help ensure that you are ready to respond quickly if ordered. Third, if a response is ordered, appellate counsel is generally much more familiar with the procedural and jurisdictional quirks of these rare writs, and will often be in a better position to show the appellate court why the writ should not be granted based on appellate counsel’s wider experience in appellate standards of review. And finally, separate appellate counsel can allow your trial counsel to stay focused on the main litigation, which is most likely moving forward even though the writ is pending.

If you are on the receiving end of an extraordinary writ — whether it is a writ of certiorari, a writ of mandamus, or a writ of prohibition, consider engaging appellate counsel for a substantive consultation and/or to appear on your behalf in the appellate court. If we can help, feel free to contact us at 813-778-5161 or fill out our intake form here to initiate scheduling a consultation.

What Are Costs on Appeal in Federal Court?

It costs money to print paper copies of briefs. Are those costs recoverable in a Federal Appeal?

When the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeal decides an appeal, the case is not quite over. In addition to making the determination of whether to seek rehearing or rehearing en banc, the winning party should also be ready to deal with filing a bill of costs, in addition to considering whether the party is entitled to an award of attorney’s fees (which we’ll cover in another blog post). What are those costs and when are they owed?

When is a Party Entitled to an Award of Appellate Costs?

Under Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 39, costs are automatically taxed against the losing party if the judgment is affirmed or reversed in full and the Court does not rule otherwise. If there is a partial victory, costs are only taxed as the Court orders. So in most cases, one party is going to end up paying the other party’s costs.

When Must the Party Entitled to Costs File the Bill of Costs?

A bill of costs is due to the appellate Court no later than the later of 14 days from the Court’s opinion issuing, or 14 days from the date the Court rules on a timely post-opinion motion for rehearing or rehearing en banc. Fed. R. App. P. 39(d). The bill of costs be itemized, verified, and include receipts if copies were made by an outside vendor.

What Types of Costs Are Appellate Taxable Costs?

While a party may have paid other kinds of costs to their counsel or vendors on appeal, only the costs specifically set out in the rules are taxable on appeal. There are two categories of costs: Those awarded by the appellate court, and those awarded by the trial court.

Which Costs Are Awarded by the Appellate Court?

As to the appellate court, the party against whom costs have been taxed must both pay the court’s docketing fee, and the costs the other side incurred making paper copies of documents that are required to be submitted to the Court.

Specifically, the rules provide that the appellate court shall award costs of “producing necessary copies of a brief or appendix, or copies of records authorized by Rule 30(f).” FRAP 39(c). How many copies that is depends on which Court you are in. The default rule under the Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure require service of 10 copies of the Appendix on the Court, along with one copy to each separately represented party, Fed. R. App. P. 30(3), in addition to providing the court with 25 paper copies of each brief and serving two paper copies on each separately represented party. Fed. R> App. P. 31(b). But appellate courts are expressly invited to set their own rules on the number of copies, and the Eleventh Circuit has thankfully reduced the number of trees that become recoverable costs.

In the Eleventh Circuit, a represented party likely filed 2 copies of the appendix, see 11th Cir. Rule 30-1(d). If the case was set for oral argument, the party probably filed three additional copies of the appendix, so the count goes up to 5. Id. It also includes “[o]ne originally signed brief and six copies (total of seven)” copies filed with the Court, along with a paper copy to each party separately represented. 11th Cir. R. 31-3. Count the number of

How Do You Calculate the Costs Awarded by the Appellate Court?

The appellate docketing fee is authorized by statute, 28 U.S.C. § 1913, and is set by the administrative office of the U.S. Courts. Effective December 1, 2020, that docketing fee was set at a flat $500 fee.

The cost of the copies is calculated by multiplying the number of pages required to be filed by a per-page fee that is the greater of the actual costs incurred, or the maximum per-page cost set by each Court of Appeals, which shall reflect local costs and “should encourage economical methods of copying.” Fed. R. App. P. 39(c). In the Eleventh Circuit, that per page figure is currently set at 15 cents per in-house copy, and a max of 25 cents per commercial reproduction, when also supported by receipts showing your actual expenditure. The Eleventh Circuit also has a specific fillable form it expects parties to use as the bill of costs [.pdf]. These costs are generally included in the mandate by the Clerk of Court.

What Costs Are Awardable in the Trial Court?

There are a few other costs specifically taxable by filing an appropriate motion with the trial court, but they usually only apply if the Appellant (the party that lost before the trial court) wins on appeal. Those costs are:
(1) the preparation and transmission of the record;
(2) the reporter’s transcript, if needed to determine the appeal;
(3) premiums paid for a bond or other security to preserve rights pending appeal; and
(4) the fee for filing the notice of appeal.

Generally, the appellate court affirms the trial court’s judgment, there is no basis to request these fees, because they weren’t paid by the Appellee. Still, if you win as an appellant, don’t forget to keep an eye on these fees, which can add up! You will be required to provide supporting documentation (such as receipts) so be sure to keep those as you make the payments.

How Do You Collect Costs Awarded?

In the Eleventh Circuit, parties are required to mail the costs awarded to the other side directly, without further action by the Court.